161 reviewssorted by Newest
Where is my pencil?
I ordered this eye pencil and some other stuff . Everything was delivered except this pencil. But it was marked as delivered. I did claim, after few days they sent me message that they can’t resend and refund, because it was delivered.
Item arrived in crushed boxes
Not sure of the quality yet. Might have been melted. Tbt
Perfect and easy
Using as eyeliner. Really easy to apply. Smudge for shadow
Recommends this product
Old and crumbling, beautiful color.
Dried up and came out entirely from the tube. Then it crumbled. And yes I closed the top properly. Could have already been old in the store. Beautiful color otherwise, but must be used with primer, otherwise it collects in crease.
Customer review from bluemercury.com
Excellent product!
Absolutely love this product! Works so well and lasts so long.
Love it
I am fair with green eyes and I love these creamy eyeshadow sticks…they are so easy and quick to apply and the shades are beautiful. I will definitely be buying more. They blend easily and have good staying power. They also don’t irritate my sensitive eyes. Highly recommend!
Recommends this product
Customer review from spacenk.com
Online order gone bad
It's an excellent product however Do NOT order online. The first one survived shipping however the second one arrived obviously had been opened, apparently maliciously turned all the way so the stick was totally out of sheath with the point smashed!!!! Buy in store ONLY save trip and hassle of returning plus weird experience explanation!!!! So disappointed 😢
Recommends this product
Broken liner within a month of purchase
The eye stick worked well for about a month. The color is beautiful, and wears well for hours, even through workouts. I've used color sticks for years but this was my first Sisley. Although I kept the color stick at a low level, it snapped inside of the tube, making it unstable for application. The product then seemed to dry out a bit, which makes sense because it is not secure in the tube. I love the Sisley lipsticks and liners, but for the price, I don't think I'll purchase again. There are likely comparable products at BlueMercury worth a try.
Customer review from bluemercury.com
Response from bluemercury.com
Hi. We are sorry to hear you aren't enjoyig your phyto-eye twist. Please reach out to team@bluemercury.com so we can further assist you.