Allen Edmonds ReserveMaxwell Plain Toe Five Eyelet Derby Dress Shoes
Product Details
Web ID: 540485714 reviewssorted by Newest
Lovely
I cannot speak to the longevity as I have just worn them only once, but they are very comfortable and look lovely
Customer review from allenedmonds.com
Excellent Quality and Fit
Across the board an excellent shoe. Good looks, nice fit, no quality control issues. I own a number of shoes in this price point from other brands and this shoe compares favorably to them. I will order another reserve shoe style in the future.
Customer review from allenedmonds.com
Review late May 2026
This shoe is the most comfortable shoe that I've ever worn. The finish and leather appear above average in quality. The high level of craftsmanship results in a shoe that is very durable.
Customer review from allenedmonds.com
Fabulous Footware
The Maxwell Derby shoe is made like the custom shoes of decades ago —- The fit, the construction, the materials are exceptional. They look and wear of the Derby’s (I have since purchased all colors) make them a pleasure to wear. I am very picky about my shoes and these shoes hit all the important points for me —-
Customer review from allenedmonds.com
Great Fit
I have a wide fore foot and a narrow heel —- the shoe fits great. I bet I’ve spent $1,000’s trying find a shoe that’s comfortable and I can wear all day.
Recommends this product
Customer review from allenedmonds.com
Great fit and finish
The fit and finish of the Maxwell is superb. They feel great and I appreciate the quality construction throughout
Customer review from allenedmonds.com
Beautiful shoe, well made
Perfect condition. Beautiful in every way. MADE IN USA!!!
Recommends this product
Customer review from allenedmonds.com
Decent shoe for a workhorse dress shoe in rotation
I bought the chili pair last year. They are a great comfortable and beautiful shoe. This one is really minimalistic, however the last is a bit more refined on these than on the original last used for park avenue. However, I find these slightly run about a quarter size too large. I have a 9 and I wear them fine, but if I had a choice I would have sized down to a 8.5 for a real snug fit. The heels run a bit sloppy on these (also including the cordovan reserve wingtip I have) for some reason the heels are too wide. Overall I'm satisfied and the shoes are amazing for the price I waited for. The leather is more premium than what you would find on their mainline. And they take a polish very beautifully. Typical allen edmonds fit and finish/attention to detail (or lack thereof) on these as well, but at this point, having so many other shoe brands I own, I find that part of it not a complaint anymore but just a quirk that adds to the charm for this brand (for me).
Recommends this product
Customer review from allenedmonds.com